Campus Capitalist Group: We Were Denied Official Status Over Concerns We Make People Feel ‘Unsafe’

Katherine Timpf

National Review

7th February 2017

The student senate at Santa Clara University has voted against giving official status to the school’s chapter of Turning Point USA after concerns were raised that approving the group would be “against [the students’] humanity. ” According to the minutes from the meeting, sophomore senator Alex Perlman said he believed that “the benefits [of] being part of this organization” were “outweighed by the amount of people who feel uncomfortable with people being part of this charter organization. ” Multicultural Center Director Issac Nieblas said that “the organization .

. . is against our ideals as a Jesuit philosophy and against our humanity and senators need to think about that before voting.

” Several attendees expressed concerns that some other schools’ chapters of the group had invited provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos to their campuses. And TPUSA petitioner Caleb Alleva told the Daily Caller that the general idea behind the opposition was that having the group on campus would make people feel “unsafe. ” First of all, I keep wondering when campus leftists will realize that their overblown reactions to the possibility of having Yiannopoulos at their schools are exactly what’s keeping him employed.

After all, as I discussed in December, people freaking out about Yiannopoulos is the foundation of Yiannopoulos’s entire career, and the whole “I’m a hero for free speech in a culture where free speech is under attack!” shtick wouldn’t work so well if people didn’t keep stopping him from being free to speak. Second of all, characterizing TPUSA speakers as “Yiannopoulos and people like him” is misguided. For example: I myself have given speeches for TPUSA, and I’m a libertarian whose views on certain issues lean further to the left than those of many Democrats.

As the TPUSA petitioners at the meeting repeatedly pointed out, the organization has no party affiliation and invites people of all persuasions. What’s more, even if TPUSA did plan to invite Yiannopoulos and people like him . .

. then so what? Listen up, kids: The appropriate response to a viewpoint that you disagree with is not to attempt to silence it. Not only will you fail (ever hear of this thing called “the Internet”?) but you’ll also miss an opportunity for an educational, discussion .

. . which is pretty clearly the exact kind of opportunity that a university should be encouraging.

Oh, and by the way — if you really are someone who feels “unsafe” because a group has official status on your campus, then you have some very serious growing up to do. If you’re a student at college, that means that you’re an adult. There are people in this country your exact age risking their lives in literal warzones right now, and I’d advise you to gain some perspective before embarrassing yourself by opening your mouth again.



Leave your comments, questions and feedback on this article below. You can also correct any listing errors or omissions.